6930 E. Chauncey Lane, Suite 295, Phoenix, AZ 85054 Monday – Thursday: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM  ·  Friday: By Appointment
Literacy & Learning

Auditory Processing Disorder: What Parents Should Know

Your child passes hearing tests but struggles to listen in noise. What APD is, why experts debate it, how it overlaps with language, and what support is discussed.

By Speech Me Therapy
· 6 min read

"He hears fine, he just doesn't listen." Many parents have heard some version of this, or said it themselves. A child passes a hearing test, yet seems to miss directions, asks "What?" constantly, or falls apart in a noisy classroom. Somewhere along the way, someone may mention auditory processing disorder, often shortened to APD or CAPD. This post explains what the term means, what professional groups and researchers say about it, and why you'll find honest disagreement among experts. It's a summary of published guidance, not a way to diagnose your child.

What is auditory processing disorder?

The American Academy of Audiology (AAA) uses a definition that says "(C)APD refers to difficulties in the perceptual processing of auditory information in the central nervous system."[1] Put simply, the ears may detect sound normally, but the brain has trouble making sense of what it hears.

A group of European clinicians and researchers describes it in a similar way: APD affects people "who have normal hearing sensitivity but who experience auditory processing difficulties in everyday life," which show up on more demanding tests "such as speech in noise or complex non-speech sound perception."[2] You may see it called "auditory processing disorder" or "central auditory processing disorder"; the European paper treats the two as names for the same condition.[2]

What signs make parents wonder about it?

The AAA guideline lists behaviors that are often reported or observed, including:[1]

  • "difficulty understanding speech in the presence of competing background noise"
  • "frequent requests for repetition and/or rephrasing of information"
  • "difficulty following directions"
  • "difficulty following rapid speech"
  • "a tendency to be easily distracted"
  • "academic difficulties, including reading, spelling and/or learning problems"

Here's the important part: the same guideline says that "Many, if not most, of these behavioral manifestations and characteristics are not unique to individuals with (C)APD." They can come from other conditions, so their presence "should only place the individual at-risk for (C)APD and not be treated as a definitive diagnostic indicator."[1] The European group agrees that "there are no core symptoms unequivocally and specifically indicative for APD."[2] In other words, a child who struggles to listen in noise could have many different reasons for it.

Start with hearing: Every source here begins by making sure a child's ears and hearing are working normally. Critics of the APD label recommend "to establish that hearing and middle ear function are within the normal range" as a first step.[3] Our post on hearing and speech explains why hearing matters so much for talking.

Why do experts disagree about APD?

This is a topic where you'll find professionals on different sides, and it helps to know that going in.

The AAA guideline acknowledges that "controversial issues remain in this clinical practice area," but holds that decades of evidence establish (C)APD as "a 'true' clinical disorder."[1] The European authors say APD "is attracting increasing interest and recognition as a clinical entity," while noting "there is ongoing debate regarding its diagnosis and management."[2]

Other researchers are more skeptical. A 2019 paper by a group of audiology and language researchers agrees that "there is an absence of consensus and a lack of a universal standard," and argues that "APD cannot be differentially diagnosed at the moment because there are no valid methods to accurately do so."[3] They point to a study in which diagnosis rates "can range from 7 to 93% depending upon which of previous proposed criteria are applied, even using the same test battery."[3]

A big part of the debate is overlap with other conditions. A 2016 systematic review compared children with suspected or diagnosed APD with typically developing children and found differences in "auditory and visual functioning, cognition, language, reading, and physiological and neuroimaging measures." It concluded that their listening difficulties "may be a consequence of cognitive, language, and attention issues rather than bottom-up auditory processing."[4] The 2019 paper suggests that many of these children's difficulties may be better understood through "more well-defined, commonly used and almost totally overlapping learning disorders such as developmental language disorder, reading disorders or attention deficit disorder."[3]

You don't need to settle this debate as a parent. What it means in practice is that a careful look at your child's language, attention, and learning matters, whatever label ends up on the paperwork.

Can APD exist alongside other conditions?

Both sides agree that listening problems often travel with other challenges. The AAA guideline notes "the frequent comorbidity of this disorder with related language, learning, and cognitive disorders."[1] The European paper says clinicians "should not exclude the possibility of APD co-existing with other disorders," listing conditions such as "ADHD, autism spectrum disorder, language impairment, dyslexia, learning disabilities."[2] If attention is part of your child's picture, our post on ADHD, executive function, and language may help, and our post on developmental language disorder covers a common language condition that can look similar.

Who tests for APD, and at what age?

According to the AAA, "audiologists are responsible for diagnosing (C)APD," because they are the professionals who evaluate hearing.[1] It also says assessment "typically involves a multidisciplinary team, often including audiologists, speech-language pathologists, psychologists, educators, and physicians."[1]

Age matters. The AAA notes that "Many behavioral tests of central auditory processing in current clinical use require a minimum developmental age of seven or eight years," and that for younger children, testing "should be undertaken with extreme caution."[1] For very young children, it describes screening, checklists, and "close monitoring of skills and regular follow-up" instead.[1]

Language testing plays a role too. The European authors write that "a detailed receptive and expressive language evaluation may in some cases be necessary," partly to choose appropriate tests and partly "to identify language development impairments."[2] The 2019 paper explains why this matters: "Inappropriately diagnosing APD in a child with language impairment, for example can delay or hinder access to appropriate language and educational support."[3] A speech-language pathologist can assess language, and our speech and language evaluations page describes what that involves.

What kinds of support are discussed?

The published guidance describes several kinds of support. Every child is different, and the evidence behind each one varies.

  • Changing the listening environment. The AAA describes "environmental modifications" such as "assistive listening systems, clear speech, improved room acoustics."[1] Even the more skeptical 2019 authors say that where "difficulty hearing speech in noise is noted, acoustic modifications to the home or classroom should be considered, together with a trial of remote microphone technology." They add: "These should however not be offered as a substitute for language, educational, or other support required."[3]
  • Strategies and accommodations. The AAA lists "language strategies, cognitive strategies, and metacognitive strategies," along with "instructional modifications" and home supports such as "posting chores on white board."[1] The European paper calls teacher-based adaptations "of the utmost importance" for children in school.[2]
  • Auditory training. This is where the evidence is thinnest. A systematic review of interventions for school-age children found "some support" that auditory and language programs can improve auditory functioning, but "little indication" that improvements were due to the auditory features of the programs, and limited evidence of effects on spoken and written language. Its authors concluded that "The evidence base is too small and weak to provide clear guidance," and that "some cautious skepticism is warranted."[5]

For children in school, the AAA guideline notes that test results may inform an IEP or a 504 Plan, depending on how the difficulties affect a child's education.[1] If your child's language or reading is also a concern, our reading and literacy page explains how language and reading connect.

The bottom line

Auditory processing disorder describes trouble making sense of sound, especially speech in noise, in a child whose basic hearing is normal. Professional groups recognize it, but researchers still disagree about how to define and test for it, and many of its signs overlap with language, attention, and learning difficulties. A sensible path is to check hearing first, then look closely at language and learning so that no need is missed. If you're worried about how your child listens, understands, or keeps up in class, talk with your pediatrician, an audiologist, or a speech-language pathologist, who can look at your child as an individual.

Sources

  1. American Academy of Audiology (2010). Clinical Practice Guidelines: Diagnosis, Treatment and Management of Children and Adults with Central Auditory Processing Disorder.
  2. Iliadou, V. V., Ptok, M., Grech, H., Pedersen, E. R., Brechmann, A., Deggouj, N., et al. (2017). A European Perspective on Auditory Processing Disorder: Current Knowledge and Future Research Focus. Frontiers in Neurology (via PubMed Central).
  3. Neijenhuis, K., Campbell, N. G., Cromb, M., Luinge, M. R., Moore, D. R., Rosen, S., & de Wit, E. (2019). An Evidence-Based Perspective on "Misconceptions" Regarding Pediatric Auditory Processing Disorder. Frontiers in Neurology (via PubMed Central).
  4. de Wit, E., Visser-Bochane, M. I., Steenbergen, B., van Dijk, P., van der Schans, C. P., & Luinge, M. R. (2016). Characteristics of Auditory Processing Disorders: A Systematic Review. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research (abstract via PubMed).
  5. Fey, M. E., Richard, G. J., Geffner, D., Kamhi, A. G., Medwetsky, L., Paul, D., et al. (2011). Auditory Processing Disorder and Auditory/Language Interventions: An Evidence-Based Systematic Review. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools (abstract via PubMed).

Questions About Literacy & Learning?

Send us a request and a speech-language pathologist will get back to you. Consultations are free, and no referral is needed.

  • Free 15-minute consultation
  • In person in North Phoenix, or telehealth statewide
  • HSA and FSA accepted; Arizona ESA for eligible students

Prefer to talk? Call (602) 432-4495